Team Tournament Final Round

441487959 · 发表于 2012-10-13 22:15:35

快点注册登录,一起玩更精彩!

您需要登录才可以下载或查看，没有帐号？加入我们

x

本帖最后由 441487959 于 2012-10-13 22:22 编辑

http://forum.upsb.info/showthread.php?t=11772

求英语帝
FINAL ROUND JUDGING OUT

Korean style Judging :
Korean Style Judging
Judge 1
Mark & Orange
Execution: 8
Difficulty: 7
Creativity: 8
Appeal:8

Total: 31
Very interesting doubles videos. The overall presentation and the execution of each individual spinner was indeed very appealing; also, examining the video holistically only increases the enjoyment factor. Both spinners displayed decent korean linkages as well as some new school linkages. The overall execution of the clips was superb when considering the stable control but spinners retained throughout the video. All in all, this is a another great video submission by Spinny [PSH].

Yamaguchi
Execution: 9
Difficulty: 6
Creativity: 6
Appeal: 9

Total: 30
Excellent combo by e.X.e.Y's Yamaguchi. His outstanding smoothness and style was a absolute eye catcher throughout the combo. This combo definitely fit this round's korean style theme. His smoothness not only highlighted his control and confidence during this combo but also contributed to fluidity and flow of the combo. The combo was wrapped up by a clean and concise finisher giving the combo some definite closure.

Juminuwo
Execution: 7
Difficulty: 6
Creativity: 6
Appeal: 9

Total: 28
A very flashy combo by AD's Juminuwo; right off the bat jumi's flashy style and flamboyant hand movements emits and appealing aura. Juminuwo's stylistic approach to korean style is very interesting and is quite enjoyable to watch. However, there were some stumbles and split-second pauses that seemed unnatural; this in itself brings down the smoothness and brings attention to his wavering control at certain points in the combo. It's, however, a very solid combo worthy of being judged in the final round.

Judge 2
Juminuwo: 23.5/40
Execution 6/10 1 mistake in the combo
Difficulty 4.5/10 some difficult tricks and links in there
Creativity 4/10 good use of linkages
Presentation 9/10 style heavy and overall good presentation

Yamaguchi: 24/40
Execution 9/10 almost perfect combo
Difficulty 6/10 healthy amounts of difficulty in the combo overall
Creativity 2/10 some attempt to be creative
Presentation 7/10 overall good presentation but it was quite normal overall, nothing that stood out overall

Mark and Orange: 16/40
Execution 10/10 no mistakes at all
Difficulty 2/10 extremely simple combos very little attempts at difficulty
Creativity 0/10 no creativity
Presentation 4/10 weird edit together, weird segregated combos. presentation overall was quite bad

so the winner is Yamaguchi for me

(Note: I may not be entirely correct with my judging in regards to the theme so let me know if you guys have differing opinions)

Judge 3
Spinny
Execution: 8/10
Difficulty: 6.5/10
Creativity: 7/10
Appeal: 7.5/10
Total: 29/40

e.X.e.Y
Execution: 8/10
Difficulty: 7.5/10
Creativity: 7/10
Appeal: 8/10
Total: 30.5/40

Advanced Direction
Execution: 8.5/10
Difficulty: 7.5/10
Creativity: 7/10
Appeal: 8.5/10
Total: 31.5/40

Score-wise, it was quite a close battle between the three of them, with Advanced Direction having a 1-point lead over e.X.e.Y. Jumi and Yamaguchi each had their own appeals, mixing in some of their personal flavors. For Yama, I think there was a bit of Japanese style in it, and as for Jumi...well, I don't know.

Creativity-wise, if we are to stick to the definition of Korean style within the UPSB wiki, all teams performed quite well. Mark & Orange might have to pick up a bit on the technical portion of the definition, but I think they got the other parts quite well. Jumi's spinning seems to fit the definition well in that it featured a substantial amount of technicality, yet while keeping the pace and rhythm of the spinning. Yama might need to brush up on expanding the technical horizon.

Difficulty-wise, Mark&Orange, seemed to perform averagely. There are other tricks which could've added technicality (reference to Jumi and Yama's videos), or even difficulty, without sacrificing smoothness. I guess subtle tricks might do it. Yama and Jumi both performed well, yama focusing towards finger slot tricks for the desired difficulty and Jumi mixing in some stops and hand motions to further control the pen movement.

Mark&Orange, also needs to work on appeal. The spinning looked bland (for one spinner) and rushed (for the other).

But after all this, there is so much you can do to be able to truly adhere one's spinning to the "true" Korean style. I guess watching the videos of oldies PSing can be the best we can get to seeing the said style.

All this being said, I hereby declare Jumi as winner.

Final Result : Tie -.___-. 都平了

Power Style judging:

Power Style Judging
Judge 1
Advanced Direction - Ivabra:
Execution 9/10
Difficulty 8/10
Creativity 7/10
Appeal 7/10
31
--Insane linkages, that aerial into top spin trick (flawless), though I felt that you could do a little more with the finisher.

e.X.e.Y - AlvinPS:
Execution 8/10
Difficulty 7/10
Creativity 6/10
Appeal 6/10
27
--Your power tricking was ok I guess. Though, your combo felt dragged on way too long and that 1p2h move felt like it was thrown in unnecessarily into the combo.

Spinny - Cloud:
Execution 8/10
Difficulty 8/10
Creativity 8/10
Appeal 7/10
31
--He did a nice job with the top spin in the beginning but he went off-cam. D: Amazing power trick finish; great job with spreads harmonic/counters. Linkages seem easy; I may be wrong because of camera quality.

Winner: Cloud
Fits with the theme nicely. I was really impressed with the finisher.

Judge 3
spinner - execution - difficulty - creativity - appeal - total

ivabra - 8/7.5/6/8 - 29.5 (good execution and balance, nice linkages, powerful style but power tricks should be stronger for this theme, great overall)

alvinps - 6.5/6/4.5/6 - 23 (fix your camera haha good combo, but a bit long, can have stronger power)

cloud - 7/8.5/5.5/7.5 - 28.5 (zoom out a bit, hand goes offscreen once; power is strong, could have better linkages; nice beginning)

IVABRA WINS

Judge 3
Advanced Direction :

Execution: 9.5/10
Difficulty: 9.0/10
Creativity: 9.5/10
Appeal: 9.5/10

Execution: I felt some parts of the combo were slower/faster than others
Difficulty: Several of those hybrid and aerial tricks are hard to accomplish, but there wasn't a whole lot of power tricks involved imo
Creativity: I don't believe I saw many tricks being used more than 2 times, besides the power tricks.
Appeal: I liked the combo a lot, it was definitely something new and appealing, although it didn't use too many power tricks

e.X.e.Y :

Execution: 8/10
Difficulty: 8.273/10
Creativity: 8.50000000000000001/10
Appeal: 6.5/10

Execution: Some visible breaks in flow of the combo and honestly I couldn't see shit
Difficulty: I feel that most of the tricks this spinner did aren't really the most difficult tricks, although still difficult.
Creativity: I saw more power tricks in this video than the first, but some weren't executed the best.
Appeal: I feel this is kind of a stereotypical combo style of a mix of power and other tricks, so I didn't find it too interesting.

Spinny:

Execution: 9.5/10
Difficulty: 9.75/10
Creativity: 10/10
Appeal: 10/10

Execution: The combo was done great, but the catch was a little sketchy
Difficulty: Dat indexspin.
Creativity: I actually liked the way the combo linked together, especially the ending with the reversal tricks
Appeal: I came

Final Result : Another tie -.____-.还是平了

竟然都平了=，=

The solution to the tie:

Final Round v2 :

-Double submitted by the teams 可以双打
- 3 way battle. 3p
-No theme 没有主题
Videos due on the 20th

加油

mhl · 发表于 2012-10-14 00:15:41

无力吐槽，ss那个酱油回合已经很无力了= =

Altynai · 发表于 2012-10-14 02:19:53

其他大神加油来自: iPhone客户端

ptrandpxq · 发表于 2012-10-14 09:35:05

spinny这么强

维斯SUPER曼 · 发表于 2012-10-14 10:39:45

其他大神加油 = =

		自动登录	找回密码
密码			加入我们

Team Tournament Final Round

快点注册登录,一起玩更精彩!

“群雄激战”大赛

铁人

星

首届全国赛